I've made all the same observations you have, will. I think it's natural that what you think is a fair offer will look pricey to somebody else, and vice versa. It's not always easy to figure out how everybody else values other players, especially the younger guys, plus I'm sure we all follow our own team's players more closely than we do the rest of the league (excluding Mets, obviously). People also tend to look to buy low, and grab guys when they think their value is down. I've gotten several offers for Mike Young, for example. None looked particularly good to me, but I look to buy low too so I don't take it personally. A lot of times I'll throw something out just to get a sense of a person's interest in dealing or acquiring a particular player; if they counter-offer, I know I'm warm. I've haggled with a few people, which is fun even if nothing comes of it. Yes, I do get the sense that some people don't follow along that closely (or in the case of Valadius, at all). But most people check in at least once a week. I have a pretty good idea at this point of who'll respond quickly and who won't. (PS the overwhelming majority of my trade offers have been rejected. Some of which -- i.e., potential deals several weeks ago that involved Ichiro or Liriano -- I am quite happy were rejected.)