The answer to all questions is, of course, we don’t know. There’s no way to know. What I do know is that the man sat up there for just over a calendar year with no answers. Nothing to offer. Completely befuddled. I don’t know if he was part of the problem, but he certainly wasn’t part of the solution.
I would have fired him after the 2025 season. 83 wins with that team, that payroll warrants firing. 4 months of futility with no answers made it patently clear. And 89 wins the year before isn’t enough to offset that. But the Mets chose to bring him back, and even those in favor of it agreed he should have a short leash
I get that it’s tough to fire a manager on April 21. But a 12 game losing streak is fucking insane. By the time you get to May 24, it’s obvious he has to go. Hanging onto him for another month is inexcusable.
And it’s not just the losing. We saw some of the dumbest baseball you’ve ever seen. Mental errors, getting picked off, no one backing up bases. For what it’s worth, that kind of stupid play has largely disappeared once Green took over. I no longer look at my TV wondering if anyone has ever played the game before.
there was no reason to keep him another month, long after it was obvious to everyone, other than hubris. They didn’t want to admit they made a mistake. And that’s my biggest concern going forward. Will Stearns admit he fucked up and do things differently? Or will this offseason be another example of him being stubborn and doubling down.