Greg Maddux, RHP, 42 years old, 6'0", 170 lb, future HOF, genius Positives : 347 wins, career ERA of 3.11, ERA+ of 134, 3273 strikeouts, career BB/K ratio of 3.37 etcetera etcetera yada yada. He's posted ERA's over 4 the past few seasons, but he's still at or below the league average anyway. You can't argue with his legacy, his ability, or his competitiveness. Little injury history to speak of. His knowledge would benefit the young pitchers on the staff. My first instinct when considering this guy is "Screw Maddux", but the fact is, he turned in a better season than Glavine did, at the same age, for less money. He's tossed close to 200 playoff innings as well. Negatives : For what it's worth, he's got the former Brave tag, but that was a few years ago. He doesn't throw as many innings as he used to. Wears glasses. I dunno. The more I think about it, the fewer negatives I find. Upside : I don't know about a HUGE upside, but it would be reasonable to expect 190-200 IP with an ERA around 4.00 given what he's been doing the past few years. Downside : With geezers like Maddux, there's always the possibility of a precipitous decline in ability, or an increased risk of injury. Health Status : Suffered from a strained back last September which limited his innings down the stretch. Tweaked a hamstring back in July or something, didn't miss a start. what it would cost the Mets : He's got an $8.75 million player option (he'll probably decline). The team holds an $11 million option. Padres GM Kevin Towers is confident the Padres can bring him back at approximately the same price as last season ($10 million). It would likely take a significantly higher offer (or at least a guaranteed second year) to pry him out of sunny San Diego. Would you go 2 years/18-20 million for Maddux? Would it be worth it : Sure, why not? I think the Mets would have to take a serious look at the guy, and at least find out what it would take to bring him in. 10-12 million should buy you league-average performance, superior knowledge, and playoff experience, right?