I thought of Randy Jones too, but I think, perhaps incorrectly, that his number with the Mets would be better than -0.2. I'm really stumped over the Pirate. Could it possibly be Richie Hebner?
When I answered Pete, I was answering the "abstract identity" question, not the strategically part. Answering the question as intended, it still might be Pete, but it also could very well be Diaz.