Ceetar wrote: I think Reyes should play again, I don't think he should be barred from the game. He's definitely better than some of the guys on the roster, positional adjustments aside. but.. he's not good enough to override the baggage in my eyes. I generally don't think teams should consider off-field/off-season stuff very highly, but it's too much here. It's too much for him to basically succeed off it. (he'd be wallowing away on the Rockies otherwise, not possibly joining a contender) It's too much given Wilpon's history. But more so, i think it might be too important off the field. If he comes back, he'll get more cheers than when he came back as a Marlin. The incident will be forgotten. People who point out he's still an abuser will be mostly ignored because he hit that home run to win that game. He served his time, within his job, but it's gotta be more than that. If he were to come back I want him volunteering in a domestic violence cause, or escorting women to Planned Parenthood, or something _actually_ redemptive. I mean, look at Aroldis Chapman. Violently shot up his garage in anger at his wife/girlfriend and I doubt anyone's harassing him about it or booing him at Yankee Stadium. Basically forgotten? This is a really good point. We -- fans in general, if not us specifically -- tend to have short memories, especially about off-field stuff. But it's important that we don't. It's what Maggie Wiggin tweeted yesterday: "A mistake is locking your keys in the car or spilling coffee. Putting another human being in the hospital is a choice." If we're ever going to change the culture, then we need to remember these things. And from a baseball standpoint, I really don't know. He's been mediocre the past few years. Is it worth taking a flyer on a rejuvenated, excited Jose Reyes? Maybe, but like Ceetar said, we need to bring the baggage with it and make sure we take care of it in the open.