I've been harping on this since BEFORE the deadline (and they blew last year's too). So putting aside that they were favored to win the division both years and _didn't_, let's specifically talk about the deadline. Givens was a good pickup. They needed relievers. They probably needed one more. They needed offense, specifically, they needed power. We see how the Mets go when their boppers aren't bopping. Daniel Vogelbach, Naquin, Ruf, etc have very specific use cases where you can maximize what's mostly 1-tool. J.D. Davis, was, and is, the better _ballplayer_ and to me, you always try to have the better ballplayer, with exceptions for being blocked, getting more versatile and flexible with lineups and playing time, which isn't something that platoon players generally give you. Granted, Davis is poor defensively, but that wasn't really what the issue was. The Mets wouldn't have wanted to move Escobar to second to play Davis at third and McNeil in the OF when Marte went down, but it's probably better _offensively_ than using Guillorme as much as they did. And I don't want to denigrate Luis too much, because he did well! but he has like negative power and lack of power was one of the Mets issues. (Davis would've been second on the team since the deadline in HR) And then there is catcher. Whatever lies we want to tell about McCann being somehow key for a rotation of veterans, he can't hit. Nido also can't hit. No one can hit. Álvarez, can probably hit. Wilson Contreras, can hit. Some other type of move that might've been out there, also probably better than McCann. It boils down to the Mets deciding they were "good enough". Getting platoon guys and pinch runners are playoff-shoring up moves, not 'try to win as many second half games as possible' moves. The Mets should've been the better team. But, granted, thanks to above average player development and trust in rookies, Atlanta is typically underrated. the _Mets_ though, should've known this. The signs were there that despite 'talent' and 'projections' suggesting the Mets were the better team and they'd just have to play normally to win the division, they might actually have to step it up and not coast.... ...unless you're okay with simply a wild card berth. So either the Mets were fine losing the bye, or they mis-evaluated the needs of the team and the strength of the competition. So in some sense, they absolutely blew the trade deadline.