"Does anyone really think it's fair that only about 5 teams have a shot at signing that Japanese pitcher who's a hot item? Edgy, I'm looking at you." Maybe the Japanese pitcher does. Seriously I can't understand how people can be in favour of things like salary caps et al that only serve to increase the profit margin for the members of a non-meritocratic** bunch of people called baseball owners. The reality is, people who play major league baseball are EXTREMELY talented being in the very top echelon of their profession they should be able to extract market rates for their talent. There's a LONG standing argument that 'the clubs develop players etc ...' but that's covered by the 6 years of NON MARKET value service that they give to the club. I'd argue that THAT in itself is way too much, but that's me. In football, players sign contracts, if they're over 23 and the contract's over, it's over and they're free to do whatever they like. If they're 23 or under they can move to whomever they like but the club whom they are with will get a level of compensation (based on development time at club and market value), but only if that club has offered them another contract at the same or greater salary. Similarly clubs have no right to 'trade' a player. Player's can be transferred but only with their agreement. Now, players generally feel that if a club doesn't want you, you're better to move on, but if you want to stay and fight for your place that's up to you. I'm not saying it's perfect, indeed the problems that agents The reality is, players are people earning a living, sure they're highly paid, but they're just like you and me in lots of ways. ** My point here is this, owners are given a guaranteed revenue stream from MLB just for being owners. As has been shown by (in it's most extreme case) Florida this year, the Pirates and most d is possible to invest very little money in the 'on-field product', receive that money and have no 'penalty for it'. In other words there's no punishment for your team performing badly and you can simply continue to cash the cheques. This is the BIG problem with the absence of promotion/relegation.