Thanks to Valadius' hint, now let's get rid of the non-Yanks from Yancy's list: Yancy Street Gang wrote: 126 possibilities (pitchers with losing or .500 records who debuted in 1986 or later) Jason Anderson Tim Burke Paul Gibson Lee Guetterman Felix Heredia Graeme Lloyd Mike Stanton Frank Tanana Allen Watson Dave Weathers Lloyd's Australian, Heredia's Latin, so they're out. Stanton's out because he was guessed. Guetterman, Anderson, Burke, Watson, and Weathers haven't really been around long enough to be in any kind of HoF, which leaves Tanana and Gibson. Gibson's done a lot of coaching around LI, but I guess my guess is going to be Frank Tanana.