I think the knock on Belle is that he ate puppy dogs for breakfast. He just wasn't a nice guy, and when a guy is statistically on the borderline for his career, it's those types of things that sway you. I hated Belle; when I was living in Rochester, he was a total dick when the O's came up to play their annual exhibition, and that really stuck with me. You throw in the other incidents (like throwing a ball at a journalist and mysteriously changing your name from Joey to Albert) and it sticks in your craw, and you don't want to recognize the good things, because he didn't really do enough on the field to transcend that. That said, the argument for Belle is my argument for Jim Rice; he was dominant for a couple of years -- the scariest hitter in the league.