And I'll play the part of Bean Stringfellow: Contribution during the past season: 28 saves, good for tenth in the NL. Overall performance: 3.94 ERA, only a half run higher than his career average, and a .271 BAA and 1.47 WHIP, only slightly higher than his career average as well. Special qualities of leadership: Agreed, not a factor. Public appeal: What's more appealing than a closer coming in, fans on their feet, and shutting down the opposition in a big spot? The length and consistency of his career contribution: 2-0 career postseason, including one WS ring. Came off a 2004 season with the Mets that saw him post a career high 158 ERA+. The record of the Player�s past compensation: Agreed, coming off a very modest contract. Highly underpaid for a guy with almost 90 saves in the past three years. Comparative baseball salaries: Bullpen salaries are rising, but the relief pitchers signed in previous seasons would also come into account. The existence of any physical or mental defects on the part of the Player: Coming off an injury which affected his performance, but he's now completely healed. And the recent performance record of the Club including but not limited to its League standing and attendance as an indication of public acceptance: I'm not saying Looper sells tickets, but this club was very good last year, and Looper led the team in saves.