Well, some of it is bad luck. If Billy Wagner doesn't blow out his arm in 2008, the team is in the postseason. Last year's injury plague would have stopped any team in the majors. The team had players in every position on the DL, including all five of their best (four of them for most of the season). Can't really blame management for that. Nor can you really blame the trainers, unless you're desperate for meaningless scapegoats. It's not like they're doing anything differently from any other team and you can't blame them for things like Bay's concussion, Wright's beaning, Reye's thyroid, Martinez hurting himself changing his uniform, Sanchez's car crash, etc. Many of the other things people whine about is pure hindsight. If Mets bloggers were the team's trainers, they'd be putting people on the DL for hangnails. As far as personnel is concerned, whenever they take a chance, it doesn't work. No one ever predicted Jason Bay would stop hitting HRs. Everyone was delighted when Beltran and Santana were signed. Oliver Perez was a risk -- that's why he was the team's second choice -- and it was a bad signing, but there was no better pitcher available at that point. The amount they paid is irrelevant: if he had signed at half the salary, the team would still have had the same problem with him. The team should have released him at the All-Star break, but, really, that was not going to make any difference. It's similar with Castillo -- and, despite everything, he did what he was expected to do with the bat, with a more than respectable .366 OBA during that time. He's not much good defensively, but Reuben Tejada would kill for a number like that. You judge a player by what he does on the field, not how much he's paid. Again, he probably should have been released in July, but that would not have improved the club all that much. The team's failure this year was due to the fact they stopped hitting in July and August. They are near the bottom in all major hitting categories and quite respectable as far as pitching is concerned. Minyana has made some bad trades (most notably, Heath Bell, who didn't need to be traded) but plenty of good ones (Ryan Church, John Maine, Delgado). He's made some bad signings (Perez, Igarashi, Matthews) and some very good ones (Martinez, Wagner, Rodriguez (whose issues are personal, not on the field*), R.A. Dickey). He also drafted Pelfrey, Davis, Murphy, Neise, Parnell, Thole, Tejada, Fmart, Duda, and Gee -- a nice crop of young players. I think that Minyana should be replaced, not because he's done a bad job, but because the fans, rightly or wrongly, blame him. Manual should go for the same reason. But too much of the problems in the paste four years were things that were beyond their control *If the team were running away with the division, people would be much more forgiving. He'd also have less time for texting.