While it's true Mays hit only .211 in 1972, their regular CF, Don Hahn, hit only .229. So using Mays was not a big drop off. Mays also had three times the number of home runs, a better OBP (.303 vs. .285), better slugging (.344 vs .290), and a better OPS+ (81 vs. 76). Mays was certainly near the end of the road -- and he knew it -- but the Mets didn't have anyone better. If Hahn had gotten Mays's ABs, the team would not have won the pennant. (And Dave Schneck and Rich Chiles, the other center fielders for the team that year, made Hahn look like Mays in his prime. Jim Gosger had a higher BA than all of them, but his OPS was worse than Mays, too.) This also doesn't factor in that Mays was a box office draw, deteriorating skills or not. Mays was a reasonable choice to stay with the team This wasn't a case of Mays hanging on too long. It was a team that needed him resigning him because he would draw fans and would be better than any of their other options.