Frayed Knot wrote: In a way it's akin to players -- like Ronald Acuna, Ozzie Albies and, hell, half the Braves lineup -- who accept offers buying out their pre-arb and arb (and sometimes early FA) years for more than they'd be making that early in their career but ultimately less than if they went season by season AND IF they wind up turning into stars. Those players are giving away part of their ceilings but also raising the floor and acting as a hedge in case they don't make it big. And, as in the BLA offers, those young Braves had the choice of Not signing a long term deal w/the club and instead 'betting on themselves' in order to gain higher future pay. So if Acuna, Riley, Strider et al are still good in five or six years the Braves 'win' by having top-level stars on their roster for mid-level money. On the flip side, the Phils tried that strategy with Scott Kingery and have paid him some $20 million dollars in 2021-2023 for what at this point is one hit over 19 ML ABs despite him being in now what should be his prime seasons (he's 29 y/o) so it's the club in this case that's over-paying and the player who's over-earning. I agree it's not for everyone, just as signing an early long-term deal isn't either. But I don't find it either predatory or gross, and it's certainly not a heads-we-win/tails-you-lose situation. BLA is offering a deal where they'll both help the player reach MLB as well as financially compensate his journey through the minors so that if he doesn't make it he won't find himself every bit as destitute as when he started. An impetus for this project being started was the founder's experience of how hard and poorly paying the minor league process is. lol no it's not Those extension guys are already established in America, in the major leagues and are set to make a bag of millions either way - one big or the other bigger. The guys referenced in the OP are poor and still trying to just get noticed and signed, so giving up the potential of millions of dollars one day for the chance to be slightly better than their peers now works because what else are they gonna do? Stay poor and anonymous? Obviously they could say no but the reasons are plentiful for a poor, foreign player to say yes, especially when surrounded by people looking to make money off them and giving them sketchy advice along the way. That's why it's gross and predatory. Sounds like we disagree on that.