iramets wrote: “It makes no difference what job you may have years from now: never give up,” Randolph said. “If I had given up, I would not be at Shea Stadium. If I had listened to the critics along the way, who knows where I might have wound up? I went on 11 managerial job interviews and was rejected on each one of them and it was their loss. The excuses were different, but the message was the same: ‘No job for Willie Randolph.’ ” Did Randolph not turn down the Cincinnati job that was offered to him because he wanted more money? How is that being 'rejected"? He may have been within to ask for more money, but isnt that him rejecting Cincy, not they him? If Willie had listed his compensation requirements up front, than an offer coming in below that could constitute a rejection. Alternatively, if Willie had countered Cincy's offer and Cincy declined, that could also be seen as a rejection. So technically, Willie might be speaking the truth here. Of course, I realize that the impression meant to be conveyed by that statement is that Willie went on 11 interviews and that none resulted in a job offer, which, if the Cincy report is true, is not accurate. But I think this would fall under "spinning" the truth (conveying technically true statements in a misleading manner) rather than re-writing history (making up things altogether). One can see that he is editorializing in his next sentence regarding "excuses". Any discerning listener would realize that sometimes, there are no excuses, there are just reasons. And some clubs might have passed on Willie because they felt he was not qualified for valid and legitimate reasons. But are graduations speeches meant to be held to such a level of scrutiny? Aren't generalizations and embellishments of truth allowed in speeches to convey a positive message? If we get technical, we can shoot down Willie's entire message of hard work and persistence. Sometimes it leads to great things. Other times, it results in fruitless chases of unattainable goals and wasting of valuable time that could have been spent on more modest, more attainable ventures. Even Brody says in his address that "focus, determination, and hard work is what makes all the difference." That's not technically true either. Sometimes the difference is having a rich dad who knows everybody and can make things happen for you even though you're a moron. Sometimes all the focus and determination won't make a lick of difference if your competitor is willing to blow the boss after-hours. I fully expect Willie's speech to suck. Most graduation speeches suck and Willie never struck me as very articulate anyway. But I don't think it sucked any more than regular sucky graduation speeches.