Wow, Benitez revisited. In 1999, when the Mets were in a dogfight for a wild card spot in September, Benitez was a big reason the Mets remained alive. Though I've long since forgotten the exact numbers, he was great during that run (you don't remember any memorable blown saves do you?). He had two scoreless appearances in two close games against the Pirates in the last weekend of the season. Both kept the game tied, both would eventually end up in wins. Had he given up a run in either of those games, or in any game that month, it would have been blown up and the media would have ripped him for blowing it at the worst possible time. It never happened. That post-season, he pitched 9 innings and gave up 1 run (he also allowed an inherited runner to tie the game in Game 4 of the NLDS.) That first run he gave up was in Game 6 of the NLCS in his second inning of work. Before that, he converted a save in Game 4 and didn't allow a run in Game 5 (the Grand Slam Single). Because of that one post-season run, he was accused of blowing it at the worst possible time. In 2000, Benitez was again, great in September. In the post-season, he had two blown saves in 4 opportunities. The JT Snow Game, and Game 1 of the World Series. Critics again said he melted down in the worst possible spot. Over the course of two post-seasons, he made 15 appearances with an ERA of 2.00. In 2001, because of the two memorable games against the Braves, Benitez critics changed their tune from "Benitez sucks in the post-season" to "Benitez sucks in big games". They ignore the success he had in September prior to that year and the success he had prior to those games. He picked up 5 saves after 9/11 and picked up the win in the dramatic Piazza HR game after entering the game in the 8th (he closed it out in the 9th). Even his biggest critics concede that had he blown a save at any point during that stretch, it would have been "at the worst possible time." So anything short of perfection would have contributed to this reputation. All in all, his "history of failure" can be boiled down to five games over the course of three years during which he was one of the most dominant relief pitchers in baseball. The Mets basically played with no safety net during that entire time and Benitez pitched well in countless big games. (For instance, does anyone remember that Benitez pitched 2 scoreless innings in the Agbayani Walk-Off game? Do you think they would remember if he did give up a run?) By comparison, Braden Looper had 8 blown saves in 2005 including one where he blew two separate leads to the Braves in one game. It's amazing, and sad, that Benitez has been so villified by Mets fans. His "choking" is as big a myth as Jeter's super-competitive-clutchosity.