Johnny Dickshot wrote: I don't think you can say there's a right number, especially given the opponents/parks and the DH possibility which'll change and allow roster re-sets between serieses. JD nailed it. The team is allowed to modify their roster as they move on to the next series of playoffs. In the first round, you need 11 pitchers and 14 position players. That provides the maximum flexibility. (If you pinch hit for a pitcher, you need one to replace him) Then depending on how many games are necessary to win the first round, you can determine whether ot not you have to add a starter or whether the first round early game starters have had enough days of rest so they can start the second series. Eleven looks good here, too, but a first round reliever may have to be replaced with a starter. In the World Series, the pitchers don't bat (d'oh), so they can (hopefully)stay in the game longer. And with the requirement for another bat in the lineup, that player may be added to replace one of the pitchers. That said, I'll go with 11 pitchers for the first round, and Rotblatt's list looks pretty good to me: ] S: Petey, Glavine, Hernandez, Maine/ Traschell R: Wagner, Heilman, Bradford, Feliciano, Robo, Mota, Oliver, Trachsel/ Maine Later