The thing that complicates this, in my opinion, is that relatively few of Stearns' moves looked bad at the time he made them. (Nimmo for Semien did, but few others.) The trade for Ryan Helsley was a disaster, but bolstering the bullpen when he did looked like a smart move. Tyler Rogers worked out, Giovanni Soto didn't, but less was expected of him. Helsley was a good trade that turned out badly. Another mistake was in not finding a better replacement for Pete Alonso. The Braves lost Freddie Freeman and replaced him with Matt Olson. The Mets had plenty of time to find someone better than Jorge Polanco, but didn't. I'm not sure I can point to too many mistakes beyond those. The mid-season turnaround in 2024 showed what Stearns is capable of. The mid-season turnaround in 2025 showed that he's not bullet-proof. I say the Mets might as well give Stearns a chance to turn 2026 into another 2024. I don't think he can, but we might as well find out.