The problem with these ideas isn't that you shouldn't be messing with the game. There's been messing all along, often much more radical than anything that's being proposed here. Changing the number of balls and strikes, letting the pitchers throw overhand, moving the pitching distance back, counting a foul ball as a strike--I probably would have hated all of those at the time, but I guess I'm okay with them now. The problem here is, first, that they're coming all at once. It's too much. And second, that they don't really have anything to do with baseball. Every sport has a basic logic, determined by the rules and by an evolving understanding of how to play the game. And the rules and the understanding tend to move together. Allowing overhand pitching, for instance, came about because pitchers were already throwing overhand, and a decision had to be made whether to enforce the rule or to recognize that the game had changed. The foul strike came about because hitters were abusing the spirit of the rule by repeatedly fouling pitches off without penalty. But these ideas come from outside that logic. They feel like they've been brought in from a completely different sport. They're like drunk poker rules—jacks beat queens on Maundy Thursday, and so on. And they don't address the one serious problem with baseball today, which is that the games take too damn long to play. The pitch clock seems to, but it's mostly just a gimmick brought in from football or basketball to make the game seem more efficient. It's not efficient; it's baseball, which doesn't run on clock logic. If the pitchers are dawdling, then instruct the umpires not to call them on it. If the batters are stepping out of the box and calling time too much, then instruct the umpires not let them. And the one proposal that seems to stand up for baseball tradition, banning extreme shifts, is the dumbest of all. Shifts are completely within the logic of the game; they exploit something that's been there all along but rarely utilized. They're fun as hell to watch. And they work, which turns out to be the real problem with them. What's wrong with these people? Screed over.