Halladay was, for a stretch, one of the best, if not the best, starter in baseball. I like B-R's "MVP Shares" and "Cy Young Shares" listings, because although those awards may be flawed, they do tell you something. And Halladay is 10th in all-time Cy Young Shares: 1. Roger Clemens (7 wins) 7.66 2. Randy Johnson* (5 wins) 6.50 3. Greg Maddux* (4 wins) 4.92 4. Clayton Kershaw (3 wins) 4.56 5. Steve Carlton* (4 wins) 4.29 6. Pedro Martinez* (3 wins) 4.26 7. Tom Seaver* (3 wins) 3.85 8. Max Scherzer (3 wins) 3.73 9. Jim Palmer* (3 wins) 3.57 10. Roy Halladay (2 wins) 3.50 11. Justin Verlander (1 win) 3.40 12. Tom Glavine* (2 wins) 3.15 13. Sandy Koufax* (3 wins) 3.05 I hate Clemens and didn't vote for him here because of that, but he should probably be in. Kershaw will be in some day, and Scherzer and Verlander are going to have really compelling cases too. (This list does, admittedly, fall apart a bit with multiple winners Johan Santana, Corey Kluber, and Bret Saberhagen 14th, 15th, and 17th, respectively.)