I think a lot of this is the lasting image I have of these guys. Sure, Benitez had some postseason saves and McGraw tanked some. These things happen. Ultimately, I associate McGraw with being a winner and coming through in the clutch, being a leader and a beloved Met. And I associate Benitez with his biggest failures, his trying to throw every pitch 105 MPH and ignoring his other pitches, and his general huffiness and inabilitiy to take responsibility for his own shortcomings.