Chad ochoseis wrote: What I've said is that I've seen Nimmo play and although it's clear he's not the second coming of Carlos Beltran, I don't see the same pathetic skills of, say, Daniel Murphy in left field (or even second base). I'm no baseball expert; I never even played Little League. So I may be wrong. "Pathetic" is too strong a word for it but, yeah, there have been enough balls that Nimmo hasn't reached that I believe most CFs would have gotten to most of the time. It's not bad athletics but more just the occasional bad route, bad jump, of missed first steps in a position where you'd want to put your guy who's the best in that kind of stuff. Ideally Nimmo is a LF'er (he also has an LF's arm) but less than ideally he's often had an even-less-good fielder already over there (Dom, JDD, McNeil) so that's not an option. Can you live with his defense in CF? ... yeah, if he's putting up near-.400 OBAs. Signing Springer would have allowed him to move over but then someone loses time in the shuffle. Almora or JBJ have been starters during parts of their careers but (barring injuries) don't figure to be that here. It becomes just a different way to fill the same hole: much less offense than Springer but off-set by a better (part-time) glove and significantly more ABs for Dom/Nimmo/Davis and without the fear of hitching yourself to an expensive six year deal where you wind up paying someone in his 30s based on the production he gave some other team while in his 20s And, yeah, even the most ardent stat hounds acknowledge the less than exact nature of defensive metrics. They're getting there but are still less dependable than what we've come to expect from those on the offensive side of the game.