I think there's plenty to back the arrogance claim. I'm not sure what others may say, and maybe their takes are lazy, but I don't throw around that word without backup.
JD Martinez. Let's go back to the JD negotiations in winter of 2024. JD held out until March 23 after hitting an impasse. Stearns likely felt he had the upper hand with Martinez having no other suitors. The stalled negotiations cost JD and the Mets all of spring training. JD didn't debut until the end of April. How much was at controversy? A million? 2 million? Stearns obviously felt he didn't need to give in. He was only taking JD at his price. History tells us we don't make the playoffs if JD signs elsewhere. And how much did that month cost us? In the end, the 2024 team was a $350M team that earned the third WC through a tiebreaker. They never contended for the division. My takeaway would have been "damn, we got fucking lucky. I better not make this type of mistake again". Stearns did not.
Paul Blackburn. Stearns traded for him at the deadline in 2024. He started 5 games and pitched to an ERA over 5 and a WHIP over 1.5. Many of us at the time said we had no idea what Stearns saw in this guy. After he got here, he did nothing to change our minds. Then he got hurt when his spine started leaking fluid. He was an obvious non-tender candidate. But Stearns doubled down. Not only did he tender him a contract, he ran him out there 7 times in 2025, while pitching to a 6.85 ERA and a WHIP of 1.648. He was a walking white flag. The only reason he kept getting the ball was Stearns refusing to acknowledge what the rest of us knew. In 2025, we missed the playoffs via tiebreaker.
Nolan McLean. And while he was running Blackburn and the Retreads out there start after start, he kept McLean in the minors. At one point it was silly. Everyone was calling for it. But Stearns kept him down there. And yes, there were developmental reasons to keep him at Syracuse, but the main reason was Stearns never really felt a playoff spot was in danger. He believed the team he put together was better than it was, and he didn't realize it until it was too late. That's why he panicked in September, and called up a clearly not ready Jonah Tong. You don't think that hurt his development? Stearns didn't realize until it was too late.
Jeff McNeil. The most obvious example of his hubris was dumping McNeil. Whatever you may think of the clubhouse, there was no reason to dump Jeff McNeil and pay for him to play elsewhere. He is a good quality major league hitter, and he would be the second best hitter on this 2026 team. Stearns felt so good about the roster he put together he decided he didn't need Jeff McNeil. And let's say hypothetically, that Jeff was reviled in the clubhouse. Everyone hated him. That still wouldn't be enough reason to dump him. Not with this team. By this time, Stearns should have realized that the teams he puts together don't have any margin for error. They don't have the luxury of dumping a good quality hitter with positional versatility. But he decided he didn't need Jeff.
Carlos Mendoza. But all this aside, the biggest, most glaring example of Stearns ego is Carlos Mendoza. I agree Mendoza is not the biggest problem ailing the Mets, but by now, we can see he's not part of the solution. In game missteps aside, a manager that gets this little out of the talent in the dugout is not the right fit. The Red Sox cut bait. So did the Phillies. There's no reason not to fire Mendoza. You're in last place. The offense is the worst in baseball. At worst, a new manager will result in just more of the same. You can't fall into laster place. The only reason we are keeping Mendoza is Stearns doesn't want to admit he's the wrong fit. He doesn't want to admit it was a mistake to bring him back in 2026, and it's a mistake to bring him back now.
By this point, the proudest man in the world should be falling on his sword. Firing Mendoza. Admitting we have to try something else. Taking a look at all of the organizational philosophy. Acknowledging that if every single player is falling below expectations, it's time to re-examine what they might be doing as a club that leads to this. Nothing. Stick to the line. Things will get better. Same bullshit we've been hearing since June 2025.
Once 2026 concludes, it will have been three years, over a billion dollars in payroll, and in none of those seasons will the Mets have even contended for the division. And the team president refuses to do anything different.