batmagadanleadoff wrote: Comparing their first eight seasons is fair. Yes, Wright's rookie season was a partial one, but Straw missed about a quarter of his rookie season, and missed about a third of the '85 season --when Straw was on pace to have what would've been his best season ever. Even though Wright appeared in just 69 games in his debut season, overall, Wright still had 258 AB's more than Strawberry in their first eight Mets seasons -- 4,161 to 3,903. So that's 2 less WAR's for Wright, if you wanna use WAR, which you do, in 258 more AB's. That doesn't help your case, WAR-wise. Not being on the team yet vs. getting hurt are two different things entirely. and staying on the field certainly matters, but the point is that they were roughly as good per-year and Wright played several more years - he is the best homegrown Mets hitter. and i haven't even gotten into the off-field stuff - Wright is a model citizen, Straw got into fist fights with teammates and was on cocaine - and these things mater too when you are talking about who should be retired. I'm not even sure that Strawberry is second on my list of homegrown hitters - taking not just the bat but position into account, I'd at least consider the Mets careers of Edgardo Alfonzo and Jose Reyes as being on par