How Billy Wagner has earned his Schaefer points (Sorted in order of points awarded) He seems to do better, on the whole, when he saves a one-run game with a scoreless inning. (In those cases, I always give him at least 1 point.) When he gives up runs, or is protecting a larger lead, he gets fewer points. If he were to come in with a three-run lead, and give up two and get the save, I wouldn't give him any points for that. It doesn't look like that's happened this year. I can see a few games where he seems to have been cheated. The 0.72 points on August 8, for example. DateOpponentResultPointsiphrersobbdecision06/25/2007CardinalsW, 2-11.6820003005/11/2007BrewersW, 5-41.09100000Sv07/14/2007RedsW, 2-11.09100010Sv05/18/2007YankeesW, 3-21.08110020Sv06/29/2007PhilliesW, 6-51.08100030Sv07/28/2007NationalsW, 3-11.06100000Sv04/13/2007NationalsW, 3-21.04100000Sv06/23/2007AthleticsW, 1-00.95110010W05/23/2007BravesW, 3-00.9110020Sv06/26/2007CardinalsL, 3-50.8810001004/29/2007NationalsW, 1-00.87110010Sv05/09/2007GiantsW, 5-30.87100020Sv07/22/2007DodgersW, 5-40.87100032Sv05/31/2007GiantsW, 4-20.86100020Sv08/14/2007PiratesW, 5-40.85100010Sv06/05/2007PhilliesL, 2-40.811001007/20/2007DodgersW, 4-10.76100010Sv05/04/2007DiamondbacksW, 5-30.75100011Sv07/12/2007RedsW, 3-20.75110000Sv06/15/2007YankeesW, 2-00.74100020Sv08/01/2007BrewersW, 8-50.73120010Sv08/08/2007BravesW, 4-30.72120001Sv08/18/2007NationalsW, 7-40.7100011Sv04/12/2007PhilliesW, 5-30.68110000Sv06/08/2007TigersW, 3-00.68100020Sv07/15/2007RedsW, 5-20.67100000Sv07/25/2007PiratesW, 6-30.65100000Sv05/08/2007GiantsW, 4-10.63100020Sv04/03/2007CardinalsW, 4-10.6100000Sv05/29/2007GiantsW, 5-40.5810002105/02/2007MarlinsW, 6-30.55110000Sv09/02/2007BravesW, 3-20.45121100Sv08/15/2007PiratesW, 10-80.370.210010Sv06/20/2007TwinsL, 2-60.3310001007/07/2007AstrosW, 5-30.27110000Sv07/05/2007AstrosW, 6-20.2210002105/25/2007MarlinsW, 6-20.1812112104/28/2007NationalsW, 6-20.1612002008/03/2007CubsW, 6-20.1112000008/05/2007CubsW, 8-30.1111001008/12/2007MarlinsW, 10-40.110001005/19/2007YankeesW, 10-70.0912112005/27/2007MarlinsW, 6-40.08111120Sv08/21/2007PadresW, 7-60.07111121W04/09/2007PhilliesW, 11-50.0610002006/29/2007PhilliesW, 5-20.0611002104/01/2007CardinalsW, 6-10.0412000005/16/2007CubsW, 8-10.0410000004/21/2007BravesW, 7-20.0310000108/24/2007DodgersW, 5-20.02131110