Guest NYGAMEUSED Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 RealityChuck wrote:="NYGAMEUSED"]I am a bit confused from your statement your saying it brings Fantasy to Reality - but this hobby has been going on since the late 1800's people have been collecting Game Used item dating back to the Lemon Peel BaseballsCite? Or, in other words, can you give any evidence to back this claim? Any ads from the late 1800s selling these? Any dealers, buyers or sellers ever using the term "game-used" during that era?Actually I can give plenty of examples for one, they are out there floating around being sold just check ebay or any sports auction thats proof enough!! As far as actual paperwork showing People buying and selling - thats the business end of it I didnt say the business end of it existed back then I said the hobby did of people collecting these Game Used items.cooby as your statement regarding me a Scarlet Groupie???? I don't even know who he is???Towards your question regarding chopping up Game Used pieces for baseball cards I think its disgusting. Why how do you feel about it?
Centerfield Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Have the game-used jerseys been washed or are they still sweaty?
Guest cooby Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I think it is terrible but it seems to be a popular new trend
Guest ScarletKnight41 Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 cooby wrote:Oh no, he's a Scarlet Night groupie!One of many
Guest NYGAMEUSED Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I understand why the baseball card companies did it and continue to do it but its not right at all!!!
RealityChuck Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 NYGAMEUSED wrote:Actually I can give plenty of examples for one, they are out there floating around being sold just check ebay or any sports auction thats proof enough!! I didn't know they had eBay in the 19th Century. Live and learn.However, unless you are willing to make that claim, an eBay auction is no proof that the hobby existed in the 19th Century.NYGAMEUSED wrote:As far as actual paperwork showing People buying and selling - thats the business end of it I didnt say the business end of it existed back then I said the hobby did of people collecting these Game Used items.Attacking a straw man. I didn't ask for the sales paperwork. I asked for evidence that anyone was selling game-used jerseys in the 19th century. You have asserted people in the 19th century collected "game-used items." Do you have any evidence to back up this claim? Any names of prominent 19th century collectors or dealers, for example. Any cites from a 19th century document that uses the phrase "game-used"? Any ads in Baseball periodical selling jerseys? You made an assertion. I have called it into question. Now, produce some evidence to prove me wrong.
Guest NYGAMEUSED Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 RealityChuck wrote:="NYGAMEUSED"]Actually I can give plenty of examples for one, they are out there floating around being sold just check ebay or any sports auction thats proof enough!! I didn't know they had eBay in the 19th Century. Live and learn.However, unless you are willing to make that claim, an eBay auction is no proof that the hobby existed in the 19th Century.I never once claimed that ebay did exist then, isaid you can find these items on ebay.="NYGAMEUSED"]As far as actual paperwork showing People buying and selling - thats the business end of it I didnt say the business end of it existed back then I said the hobby did of people collecting these Game Used items.Attacking a straw man. I didn't ask for the sales paperwork. I asked for evidence that anyone was selling game-used jerseys in the 19th century. You have asserted people in the 19th century collected "game-used items." Do you have any evidence to back up this claim? Any names of prominent 19th century collectors or dealers, for example. Any cites from a 19th century document that uses the phrase "game-used"? Any ads in Baseball periodical selling jerseys? Yes collected sure as mentioned earlier these items out there, if no one collected them, then how would they exist today on the secondary markets? I personally do not know the names of prominent 19th century collectors, but I can give you the name of my grandfather who passed down a collection to me of Game Used baseballs and a Jersey. As stated before the phrase"Game Used" falls into the aspect of the business end of it. I don't know if there were periodicals back then for such an item as said before back then people collected these items, an actual sale didnt necessarilly take place. I SEE THIS IS A HARD CONCEPT FOR YOU TO UNDERSTAND.You made an assertion. I have called it into question. Now, produce some evidence to prove me wrong.The insertion I made has nothing to do with the questions you ask.I stated it was a collectin hobby yet you keep referring to the business aspect of it. I dont understand why you can't comprehend the difference between someone just collecting something and a business sale
RealityChuck Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 NYGAMEUSED wrote:The insertion I made has nothing to do with the questions you ask.I stated it was a collectin hobby yet you keep referring to the business aspect of it. I dont understand why you can't comprehend the difference between someone just collecting something and a business saleSo? You haven't given any evidence that the hobby existed, either. I'm merely suggesting evidence that would prove it did, but if you can come up with something else, that's great: the name of a 19th century collector, for instance. Or any document from the time (e.g., a private letter) that talks about getting a "game-used jersey."Let's see some proof. You made an assertion, but keep changing the subject whenever I ask you to back it up.
Guest NYGAMEUSED Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I see you didnt full read my reply by accident i posted my responses in the quote part - if you read through the last quote part I answered all your questions.As far as me backing up what I said, that I did. As far as chaning the subject, I have not that's what you have been doing because you don't know the difference between Hobby collectiong and Business.But thats ok your excused, I am curious why you don't have this comprehnsion i see its a problem for you.
Valadius Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 You know, if you didn't constantly attack people's intelligence, etc., maybe we'd take you a bit more seriously.
Guest NYGAMEUSED Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Vladius so let me get this correct its ok for him to attack me because he full doesnt understand what I wrote and after explaining it the second time he still doesnt get it and continues to attack me for a 3rde time thats ok???but becuz after his second attack I attacked him back thats not ok???????Meanwhile he continuosly attacks me
Guest Edgy DC Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 RealityChuck wrote:Let's see some proof. You made an assertion, but keep changing the subject whenever I ask you to back it up.I think Chuck is wasting his time with you. It doesn't matter how far back this hobby goes.But this isn't an attack.
Valadius Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Brush it off, for crying out loud. It's not right for anyone to attack anybody, but come on, lighten up a little. Crack a joke or two.
Benjamin Grimm Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 ]Yes collected sure as mentioned earlier these items out there, if no one collected them, then how would they exist today on the secondary markets? There's a difference between someone "collecting" something and someone not throwing it out.If my great grandchildren somehow find my toaster oven in my attic years after I die, it's not evidence that I collected toaster ovens. It simply means that my toaster oven was never disposed of.]I personally do not know the names of prominent 19th century collectors, but I can give you the name of my grandfather who passed down a collection to me of Game Used baseballs and a Jersey. How did your grandfather come by these items? If he bought them from players or teams because he liked having used baseball jerseys, then he was a collector. But unless you're pretty old your grandfather probably wasn't doing this collecting in the 19th Century. I'd guess he probably bought them, either directly or indirectly, from the families that never threw them out.
RealityChuck Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 NYGAMEUSED wrote:I see you didnt full read my reply by accident i posted my responses in the quote part - if you read through the last quote part I answered all your questions.You're right. Here it is:]Yes collected sure as mentioned earlier these items out there, if no one collected them, then how would they exist today on the secondary markets?Not proof. Or, at least, no more proof than saying, "they exist, thus elves laid them on people's pillows." There are many ways these could have existed without active collectors -- they were kept by the players themselves, for example, or their relatives. You are claiming that there were actually people who went around gathering these items as part of a collection, not merely keeping one or two personal souveniers.] I personally do not know the names of prominent 19th century collectors, but I can give you the name of my grandfather who passed down a collection to me of Game Used baseballs and a Jersey. Your grandfather was a 19th century collector? Really? My grandfather was born in 1899, so he couldn't be a collector in the 19th century, and I bet I'm older than you are. What year was your grandfather born?More likely, he started collecting well into the 20th century. That's does nothing to prove your claim.]As stated before the phrase"Game Used" falls into the aspect of the business end of it. I don't know if there were periodicals back then for such an item as said before back then people collected these items, an actual sale didnt necessarilly take place. I SEE THIS IS A HARD CONCEPT FOR YOU TO UNDERSTAND.And I don't see why it's so hard to come up with evidence to show that people did actually collect these items. I did not insist you show a market and sales, just some evidence to back your claim. And saying "What else could it be?" will result in the answer "elves."]As far as me backing up what I said, that I did. As far as chaning the subject, I have not that's what you have been doing because you don't know the difference between Hobby collectiong and Business.All I'm asking is evidence that this purported hobby existed in the 19th century. You keep avoiding that and pretending that I'm asking the business existed. I am not asking that, and I never asked that. I'm asking for evidence OF THE HOBBY.I, too, am curious why you don't have this comprehnsion, but I see it's that you just want to evade the issue because you have no proof to back up your assertion.
stevejrogers Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 RealityChuck wrote:="NYGAMEUSED"]The insertion I made has nothing to do with the questions you ask.I stated it was a collectin hobby yet you keep referring to the business aspect of it. I dont understand why you can't comprehend the difference between someone just collecting something and a business saleSo? You haven't given any evidence that the hobby existed, either. I'm merely suggesting evidence that would prove it did, but if you can come up with something else, that's great: the name of a 19th century collector, for instance. Or any document from the time (e.g., a private letter) that talks about getting a "game-used jersey."Let's see some proof. You made an assertion, but keep changing the subject whenever I ask you to back it up.Chuck, Barry Halper once had a collection of GU jerseys of EVERY HOFer, that means even Pud Galvin, Billy Hamilton, Hoss Radbourn, Al Spaulding, ectDoes that mean there were dealers back then or Barry bought them from family/estates who knows, but there is a reason those keepsakes were kept
RealityChuck Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I agree. People held on to these and were later added to collections by collectors. But that wasn't the claim. The claim was that there were collectors -- people searching out the "game-used" jerseys in the 19th century. It's not that the jerseys don't exist. I'm looking for proof that collectors of these jerseys existed in the 19th Century.
Guest KC Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Maybe we should just move on. Collecting baseball uniforms is actually avery cool hobby if that's one's bag. I have a friend, actually Scarlett interviewedhim for Inside Pitch, who has almost every uniform from the 86 team and has a ot of 60's uniforms and it's pretty impressive. He was also featured on SNYa little while back too. He has a veritable museum of Mets stuff. I'm surprised everyone is trashing collecting Mets laundry, but I suppose it's moretrashing the peddling of one's wares on our little pond in cyber-space.NYGAME, if ya wanna do a low key ad stick it in the member promotion forumand if ya wanna hang out start off on a new (and better) note on somethingelse baseball related and like I said, let's move on.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Does this mean I'm no longer head of the welcoming committee?
Guest cooby Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I thought it was KC all along.Now I know it.
Guest KC Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 We love ya FK, don't ever change.I escalated shit at work today, so I thought I'd try on the voice of reasonhat for the internet ... mix it up a little.
metsmarathon Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 i'm still trying to figure out how you would talk out of hte side of your neck. i think its been glossed over in this whole discussion. i mean, sure, talking out of the front of your neck - that i'll buy. there's that whole anti-smoking commercial thing that shows just what that's all about, along with a sad sad tale of a man no longer able to swin. but the side of your neck? that's just dangerous. there's big blood vessels in the way, and a fair amount of musculature and other connective tissues. its just not even a good idea to try it. i should reconsider my approach for making friends on new forums (not that i would ever have need to find new or different online friends. y'all are the best! i've gotta just start off with ]"NEW AND DEVELOPMENTAL MILITARY HARDWARE FOR SALE!"wargame used Ammo cans!wargame used Fuze wrenches!wargame used Artillery Shells!*wargame used bullets!*wargame used Portable Inductive Artillery Fuze Setters!Det Cord & Primer NIB!Sensor Fuzed Munitions NIB!Huge selection of new and used UAVs!Huge selection of training simulators**Actual Training Manuals (TMs) and Field Manuals (FMs)! Learn the way the pros learn!>>>check back soon as we add precision guided mortars and artillery to our wide inventory!!!!<<<*not responsible for UXO**condition may vary. all training simulators are sold as is.
Guest cooby Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I think I have a general idea of what Frayed Knot looks like, but even so, I just can't picture him talking out of the side of his neck. It just sounds like it would hurt, doesn't it?
metirish Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I've heard of talking out of your arse but never the neck.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 ="cooby"]I think I have a general idea of what Frayed Knot looks like
Guest ScarletKnight41 Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Frayed Knot wrote:Does this mean I'm no longer head of the welcoming committee?Hello - He's Frayed Knot. He's damn glad to meet you!
Guest Edgy DC Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 I'm selling the shirt and tie I was wearing when I read this thread and posted in it. If anybody collects flame-used clothing, shoot me an e-mail.
Guest cooby Guests Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Frayed Knot, that picture along with your sig line is extra funny!
soupcan Old-Timey Member Posted September 21, 2006 Posted September 21, 2006 Edgy DC wrote:I'm selling the shirt and tie I was wearing when I read this thread and posted in it. If anybody collects flame-used clothing, shoot me an e-mail.Golf clap.
Zach Thornton Syracuse Mets - AAA LHP On Sunday, the southpaw tossed five shutout innings as the bulk pitcher. He gave up 2 hits, walked 2 and had 5 strikeouts. Explore Zach Thornton News >
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.