Jump to content
Grand Central Mets
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 61
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted


That shift against Lindor is so extreme. Just drop a bunt and take the gift base. A decent bunter (I know, I know, almost nonexistent in today's game) could hit .800 against thaat defensive alignment.


Posted


Gary praising the replay coordinator, and sure, I agree.



But there was approximately a 0% chance that they wouldn't challenge that play…


Posted


Fun game and post-game fireworks. Lucky on that replay, sucks to be a dback fan but the Mets fans were louder and prouder. McNeil played great. Why did Zimmo disappear? I feel like that messed up Diaz.


Posted


Nimmo appeared to have had a glove issue.



I don't know if that messed up Diaz, but it sure seemed like exactly the sort of thing that could take him off his game. Christian Walker's homer off of May was on a really good pitch, but the homer Diaz gave up to Varsho was on the hangingest slider I've ever seen him leave hanging.


Posted


Edgy MD wrote:

Excellent. Really close, but he was safe.


Maybe.



Second potentially game-flipping replay inside of a week that went the Mets way where I would have blown a gasket (and you guys would have been forced to "hear" me vent) had that flip gone against us.


Posted


I don't understand. You disagreed with the replay decision? My view was that it was clear he was safe and the call was appropriately overturned.



There have been some occasionally baffling replay decisions on tag plays or even some home run calls, but getting the first base force call right on replay is not difficult.


Posted


I was asleep by the time that happened so what I saw was via highlights and only once ... but in that viewing it didn't look like close to enough evidence to overturn.

And, remember, it's supposed to be definitive evidence not the 51% standard that seems to be used far too often.

My point is that I would have bitched about losing a game based on such scanty 'proof' and I suspect most of us here would have done the same had the shoe been

on the other foot, especially for the second time in a week.


Posted


A seemingly overlooked piece of the replay puzzle here is that a tie goes to the runner, and as they replayed that thimg over and over from different angles there was never one that made it look like the ball in the glove beat the foot to the bag. If they got there at the same time, the tie goes to the runner and overuling the call ia correct.


Posted


There is no rule which states a tie goes to the runner ... despite what most of us learned and used in the schoolyard.

And the original call was 'Out', so what the replay has to show is that there is definitive evidence that it should have

been the other way around not that you think it kinda sorta was probably the case.


Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
The Grand Central Mets Caretaker Fund
The Grand Central Mets Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Mets community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...