]This year's numbers -- .260 batting average, 26 doubles, 22 homers, 70 runs scored, 92 RBI in 575 AB -- not great. Better than anything we've had at first for a pretty long time. ]Better than Jacobs for 575 AB? Maybe not. On the other hand, maybe so. ]Probably worse defensively than Jacobs. I'll admit to ignorance on his defensive skills. How can we know one way or the other without seeing more of him, and more of Jacobs? Did you really watch a lot of Tampa's games this year? ] Discount the RBI numbers since he was in AL and had a team of rabbits ahead of him. He played for the Devil Rays, and you want to discount RBI totals? If anything, increase them. ] I'm not jumping to trade good prospects in order to get this guy as an "upgrade" at 1B. I'm all for giving Jacobs a shot. But if you can get a proven hitter, and keep Jacobs' in the system, there's nothing wrong with that.