I don't think i'd part with Milledge & Maine. Right now our rotation is Martinez, Hernandez, Maine & Perez plus AN OTHER Right now our outfield is Alou, Beltran, Milledge & Chavez If you take out two of Maine & Milledge you need to sign two free agents to make up. Right now the cost of a 'low end John Maine' looks to be about 5 years and 60 million. Replacing Milledge probably costs less in terms of money & years but more in terms of lost upside. This mets team is nicely set up to contend for another 3/4 years due to a core of Wright, Reyes & Beltran. However replacing from within is proving to be far more efficient then Free Agency at the moment (due to the hugely escalating salaries) therefore the premium on younger talent has actually got higher. There's no doubt in my mind that Maine & Milledge can be key components in a championship winning team, I can't say the same about Pelfrey, Humber & Gomez. If the twins came and said to us, Millege, Maine & AN Other for Santana would I do it? I'd think about it, think very hard and try and come up with an answer but right now, I'm not able to do it. The point smg makes about Oliver Perez is noted, though there is a "stay contending at a lower cost and get future upside aswell" combo in the twins acquiring (say) Oliver Perez, Gomez and Gotay.