="Mr. Zero"]Oliva didn't not hit home runs. hit like 220, and 32 one year. but he really played only 11 full seasons out of an 13-14 year career. not even 2000 hits. Hell, Kevin McReynolds hit 211 home runs. Doesn't mean he's a HOFer. No on Oliva. (I know, I know, it's a terrible comparison. I'm just a big McReynolds fan, and this is the first and only time he'll ever be mentioned in a HoF discussion of any kind.) I'd say yes on Dick Allen, but that brings up the issue of Jim Rice, who should be in already. No Rice, no Allen. I guess Torre's in as a manager, although I don't like it. I'd say we're being overly sentimental and New York-biased on Hodges, but I guess he has a case. He was too far before my time for me to argue one way or the other. I guess you could make a Hodges-like case for Santo too; I don't know. No Lyle without Gossage, no Munson ever. Everyone else on the list is a no for me.