i think the most important question about this thread is "what do you mean by important?" do you mean which spot in the order is it most vital that you fill it with the archetypical hitter (speedy on base guy hitting leadoff, contact hitter in the two, good all-around in three, slugger with good obp in four, slugger with lesser obp in five, and so on and so forth)? or do you mean which spot fdo you put your bestest hitter in, and so on and so forth? because if we're ignoring the archetypes, and are just going by some nebulous quality of bestest, then i'd default to put my bestest guy 4th in the order, then 3,5,2,1,6,7,8,9