d'Kong76 wrote: With regards to comment one, nobody really decides. They have a rule that if you get 10 years, you make the ballot. Grumpy HOF comment: That's a dumb rule, which I suppose is my point that I didn't clearly make but geez if you're not an all-star you're not a HOF'r and putting people on the ballot like that is a waste of time and energy. Mr. Met has more HOF credentials than Casey Blake. It's part of the basic agreement with the Player's Association, who wanted a simple set of criteria so no one felt snubbed. Personally, it no big deal. The players get some egoboo, but they know they're not getting in. It's like when I made the preliminary ballot for the Nebula award -- nice to see, but I wasn't going to even be a finalist.