Benjamin Grimm wrote: Why is Robinson Cano deciding who is in Home Run Derby? It's just a show for the fans, right? Why would he not choose to have a hometown favorite in the competition? I saw a quote where he said something about how he wanted to choose the best team possible. Why? Does this "count" too? They've taken to naming "captains" on each side and those guys get to pick their teams - although I suspect there's some league involvement as well. Cano, as defending champ, was this year's AL captain. Matt Kemp was NL captain. And, yeah, you'd think it would be smart to get some local flavor into what is essentially a meaningless contest, although it's tough to argue for kicking out one of Prince, Trumbo or Bautista to do it.