Yeah, I sometimes think we shortchange closers in this type of rating as fans in general tend to praise set-up men who pitch a clean inning but then dismiss a closer who does the same on the idea that 'it's what he's supposed to do'. On the other hand, as I've incorporated these cumulative PotY votes into our individual ballots for our year-end rankings project, I've been on the lookout to see whether the PotG results show any kind of trend towards over or under crediting starters, relievers, subs, etc., but have yet to detect a pattern.