FYI for any newbies I am on record for defending these guys against skanky girls but this sounds a bit more specific I'm on the record for "hang them from a tree"... but only if we know for sure they are guilty. I'm not on record for hanging anyone from a tree, especially a Black player (I'm sure you didn't mean it that way but that reads badly in this case). But if he is guilty, I hope at age 24, there is still time for him to figure out why violence was the option he chose against his girlfriend and learn how to ID that emotion and not do that same thing again in his life. I hope there is a path to redemption for him and still hope he can be a good person to other people. As for playing professional baseball, that's always sketchier for me. That profession is an extreme privilege, so I don't know what it would look like to retain (or re-attain) that privilege, but I would think it would have to be a stew that has most or all of these ingredients: 1) admission of guilt 2) legit remorse (what is legit? I don't know) 3) sincere apology to victim 4) serve suspension/jail time 5) therapy/DV education 6) continued work in those spaces after career resumes 7) other stuff I missed? I said before that I hope the league and the Mets make a clear point in demonstrating that they don't tolerate violence against women. So where do you go if you want to give a remorseful and rehabilitated person a second chance? I don't know. I don't blame any team that doesn't want to sign a player who has committed DV. If there's a surefire way to make sure women (and male allies) do not want to consume your product, it's to put a person who has been violent to women right in front of them. IF a team wanted to sign a guy who's done this, I think they should be out front in acknowledging the charge and the team should also join the player in doing work in education and support spaces. If you're going to go in, go all in on the rehabilitation, but more importantly, also be an ally and work for the victims. I can absolutely see the flaws in that plan, though. Which direction does everyone else's moral compass swing on this? Doing something is easy. Doing the right thing is hard.