They're not the best comps as players, but another guy who played shortstop, was beloved and overrated by both the national media and his franchise's fans was Cal Ripken. Not looking to argue one's merits versus the other, but I would suspect the votes for Jeter will be similar to Cal's. In 2007, Ripken got 98.5% of the votes (he appeared on 537 out of 545 ballots cast).