Ceetar wrote: 1 out, on the third hit of the inning to Duda, Murphy cuts it off, the runner doesn't round third, and the runner at first takes the turn and runs to second. He's halfway when he realizes and starts retreating. Murphy runs at him, and as he gets close, glances to third a little too long, which gives the runner an opportunity to dive back to first safely. You also forgot that instead of making a normal, overhand throw to Turner at first, Murphy flipped it sideways like a moron. To answer your question earlier, YES, people DO know what do to in that situation because they practice it. Rundowns and having runners hung up on the bases is indeed practiced and Murphy just fucked up, plain and simple. Hitting aside, he's not a good baseball player.