Let’s take a look at the last 5 starts for both Kodai Senga and Sean Manaea, and consider if the hook is coming too soon for who are supposed to be 1-2 in the Mets rotation: Manaea July 23 vs LAA Pulled after 5 complete innings. Mets up 6-1, 82 pitches. 2-3-4 coming up for the Angels in the next innning. Verdict: A little hasty, but this was Manaea’s third appearance of the season, so maybe defensible if he’s still stretching out. Game outcome: Mets won 6-3. Butto let up a couple of runs in his second inning of relief. July 29 vs SD Pulled after 5 complete innings, tie game (1-1), top of the Padres order coming up, 86 pitches. Verdict: too hasty. Game outcome: Butto relieved Manaea and let up one run in the 6th, and Mendoza then sent him out for a second inning which went very poorly. Mets lose 7-1 Aug 4 vs CLE Pulled in the middle of the 6th with 2 outs. Pitched 5 scoreless innings (allowing only 3 baserunners) but then let up 5 runs (including a bases-clearing homer) in the 6th with one out. Strikes out the next batter for second out, then allows a single and is pulled having thrown 29 pitches that inning (85 total for the game). Verdict: maybe he could’ve gone one more batter, but this isn’t really an awful decision. Game outcome: Mets would tie it up but lose in the 10th in large part due to clown car rules. August 10 vs MIL Pulled after first batter reaches in 5th. Mets up 6-3 at time. 87 pitches. Verdict: too quick to pull him Game outcome: Garrett came in and allowed a 2-run homer to the first batter he faced. Mets never scored again. Helsley and Diaz each allowed a run in the 8th and 9th to lose 7-6 Aug 15 vs SEA Pulled after 5 complete, Mets up 6-4, 86 pitches. Had allowed 3 runs on homers in the second and third, but had scoreless innings in the 4th and 5th. 6-7-8 coming up for Seattle. Verdict: too quick, with only 86 pitches Game outcome: bullpen lets up 7 runs. Mets get a few back but lose 11-9 Senga Jul 21 vs LAA Pulled after competing 3 inning, Mets down 4-0, 73 pitches. Threw 37 pitches in the third inning, giving up 3 runs. Verdict: defensible to pull him there after a very taxing inning and the game within reach if the bullpen could stop the bleeding. Game outcome: Mets won, 7-5. Kevin Herget with a nice outing to back up Senga’s early exit. Jul 27 at SF Pulled after completing 5 innings, Giants up 3-2, 92 pitches, bottom of order coming up in the 6th. Giants were throwing a bullpen game. Verdict: a little hasty. Senga’s had 4 outings of 100+ pitches so far this year. Game outcome: Mets won 5-3, using 5 relievers to get 4 scoreless innings. Aug 2 vs SF pulled after completing 4 innings, Mets up 5-4. 71 pitches. Verdict: way too quick for the guy who’s supposed to be the ace of the staff Game outcome: Mets won 12-6, teeing off on the Giants’ bullpen. Aug 8 at MIL Pulled with one out in the 5th, tie game (2-2, one run allowed by Senga was unearned), bases loaded (in part due to an error). Was at 79 pitches. Verdict: too quick of a hook, especially after a short outing the last time! Game outcome: Raley hit the next gut with a pitch to force in the run, and nobody scored again. Mets lose 3-2. Aug 14 vs ATL Pulled with 2 outs in the 6th, tie game (1-1), runners on first and third, 93 pitches. Had thrown 19 pitches in the inning. Verdict: probably too quick for a hook, but closer call. Could have allowed Senga to face Albies. Game outcome: Albies singled off Rogers for a one run lead. Mets would take lead a one run lead back but Helsley had a bad 8th. Mets lose 4-3.