]Their peaks may have been similar, but griffey has longevity on his side. Griffey was also a far better defensive player and better all around player. I'd suggest that Griffey's peak was better. his 5 best OPS+ years were 172, 170, 164, 155, 153. Gonzo's were 169, 150, 149, 147, 141. Gonzalez really doesn't measure up to Griffey at all.