="LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr"] A) Knight is 32 years old, and, with an ERA+ of 81 last year, is the very definition of "replacement level." (At least Figs is a local guy.) that was over TWELVE INNINGS he had a 2.28 with a sub-1 whip in 43 innings at AAA, he might not be anyone idea of great but he has a better chance than livan to give you something ] If part of the issue is getting Niese to build confidence and precision, how would getting shelled every other time out-- and getting reamed out for it in the press for the two days following-- help with getting him to trust his stuff and not overthrow (his primary issue last year)? (NOTE: The ONLY case in which I believe in the "handling New York" thing is when a player is relatively unformed.) Getting shelled worked to get Pelfrey the necessary experience. If you think Niese has what it takes to be a major leaguer then the experence, even if he gets shelled, should be good for him. and he likely won't be worse than livan. ]C) Parnell, organizationally, is slotted for the bullpen. The matter at issue with him is that he's still learning to hold onto command while going "all-out" for 30 pitches at a time. (He typically throws his fastball at 90-92 when starting; he ramps it up to 96-plus when he rears back and THROWS.) Slotting him into a spot-start/5th-starter role kinda goes against what management has planned for him, then, no? ah so THE plan is to make him a reliever, how dare we deviate from THE plan if it helps the team win. ]C) Granted, last year was a washout. But an ERA of 4.83-4.93 and ERA+ of slightly-worse-than-league-average (say, 92-95)-- highly-doable goals, no?-- would put him about a half-run ahead of the spot's performance last year (5.31 cumulative, between Pedro and the sidekicks), and better than a serviceable Trachsel in 2006 (4.97, 88). so your goal, and i think the best possible scenario, from livan is an ERA+ around 90. nevermind those other terrible scenarios (last year or worse), i wouldnt want to pencil a guy in whose best possible year is going to be below average. if you have to turn to Livan (or someone like him, such guys are always out there) inJue when 3 starters go down thats just the way it goes, but i wouldnt want to count on him to be part of the opening rotation when there are better options.