Schaefer POTG 5/11/06, Mother Nature (and PHI) 2, Mets 0.

[nymr83]

Beltran .5
Delgado .5
Wright .5
Nady 3
Traschel 2


Nady's ball had no business being caught and ina rain-shortened shutout that will get him a three from me.

[Guest Yancy Street Gang]

Nady 1
Trachsel 1
Matsui 0.5
Castro 0.5

[metsmarathon]

Trachsel 2
Castro 2
Matsui 1
Nady 1
Beltran 1

[Guest *62]

Trachsel - 4

[Elster88]

] Nady's ball had no business being caught and ina rain-shortened shutout that will get him a three from me.

Let me get this straight Nymr. Your methodology is to give no points for the two hitters who hit doubles, and to give 3 points to a guy who went 0 for 2 with an almost-double. Makes perfect sense.

Nady's ball was caught. It was a great play. Happens all the time. This ain't horseshoes and it ain't hand grenades.

[Elster88]

Box score

[Elster88]

Trachsel 2
Castro 1
Matsui 1

[Guest sharpie]

Castro 2
Trachsel 2
Nady 1

[Guest ScarletKnight41]

Trachsel - 2

[Guest abogdan]

Castro 2
Trachsel 1
Matsui 1

[seawolf17]

Trachsel 2
Beltran 0.5
Castro 0.5

[nymr83]

Elster88 wrote: ] Nady's ball had no business being caught and ina rain-shortened shutout that will get him a three from me. Let me get this straight Nymr. Your methodology is to give no points for the two hitters who hit doubles, and to give 3 points to a guy who went 0 for 2 with an almost-double. Makes perfect sense. Nady's ball was caught. It was a great play. Happens all the time. This ain't horseshoes and it ain't hand grenades.

in a game where the mets don't score yes i gave points to the guy who hit a ball that 99.9% of the time scores 3 runs. i probably wouldnt do this in a 5-4 game but if we arent going to hand out significant points in a loss then whats the damn point of this whole thing?
i liked it better when we mandated 10 points in every game btw.

[Gwreck]

Castro .75

(and that's it).

I think the switch to "as many or as few" points as you want is a good one. This game had basically nobody worthy of points. Giving out 3 or 4 or 5 points when nobody did crap devalues the times when players actually do help the team win.

[Guest GYC]

Matsui .5
Castro .5

[Zvon]

Beltran: .3
Delgado: .5
Wright: .5
Matsui: 1
Castro: 1.5
Trachsel: 1

[Theoldmole]

Trachsel 4
Matsui 1
Castro 1

[Guest Yancy Street Gang]

VOTING FOR THIS GAME IS NOW CLOSED
Totals for May 11, 2006 (13 votes)
Philadelphia Phillies 2, New York Mets 0

Name	Total Points	Points Awarded	Player Performance
Steve Trachsel	23.00	1.77	(L) 4.0 IP, 6 H, 2 ER, 2 BB, 3 SO.
Ramon Castro	11.75	0.90	1-1, 2B, BB.
Xavier Nady	6.00	0.46	0-2.
Kaz Matsui	6.00	0.46	1-2, 2B.
Carlos Beltran	2.30	0.18	0-2, BB, SO, SB.
Carlos Delgado	1.00	0.08	0-1, BB.
David Wright	1.00	0.08	0-1, BB.

CPF Schaefer Voting Results