Bret, you're killing your own argument. Whitey Ford: Ralph Houk, a managers with a pretty solid career record, gave Ford seven starts in 1967. He went 2-4, yes, but his ERA was under 2, and his WHIP was 1.11. I'm assuming there was some sort of injury that ended his career; but either way, Ford was 38. Spahn: Got 30 starts in 1965, from Gil Hodges and Herman Franks. At age 44. Cuellar: Went 4-13 when Earl Weaver gave him 19 starts in 1976 at age 39. Bunning: Maybe. His 4-14 in '68 was in 26 starts; was an injury at play there? I don't know. Either way, he finished 13-10 with two teams the following season, with good peripherals. In 1970, he was 10-15 in a full season; in '71, 5-12 with 16 starts (and 13 relief appearances), at age 39. Carlton: Was in his 40s when his career fell apart, and bounced from team to team his last few years. Pedro: Is 34 this year, still a few years younger than all those guys. Had his best WHIP in '05 since '02, when he won 20 games. Had a 148 ERA+, which although not his best, was still fifth in the NL. Is the active major league leader in ERA, WHIP, and K/BB. I still don't see how letting Pedro work out his problems makes Willie Randolph a bad manager.