Stories of Neil Walker talking extension get more legs every day, with independent reports at first, followed by quotes of confirmation from Walker, followed by quotes of confirmation by Sandy Alderson, saying he's talked with Walker's agents and will be talking with Walker soon. When, I ask you, does Sandy ever confirm anything in plain English like that? Yet I sit here and I have some pause. On the one hand spending good money on good players is a good thing. On the other hand, he’s coming off a career year combined with a season ending injury. That doesn’t scream “Time to invest!” On the one hand, three-year contracts cost you less in annual value than the big whoomp of a single year. On the other hand, that might have been more effective logic had they signed him to a three year deal before committing to his one-year burst of a free-agency-qualifying offer. That gives him the big leverage of negotiating with the whoomp year already guaranteed. On the one hand, he gave you more offense than you possibly expected. On the other, how much can you really expect that, and will the defense fade quickly now that he’s in his 30s and playing in the middle of the diamond? On the one hand, with a lot of question marks and transitions going on around the diamond, it’d be nice to have second base locked up for a few years. On the other hand, one place the Mets are rich in prospects seems to be in the middle of the infield. Wouldn’t it be smarter to invest that money in a spot where they are seemingly more impoverished? Well, on the one hand, he’s expressed his willingness to move, not only giving you an occasional alternative at first, but giving some serious insurance at third against David Wright not bouncing back following serious surgery. Yabbut, on the other hand, isn’t Flores long-term insurance against a fading Wright? Isn’t Cecchini? Don’t they already have Walker locked in for 2017, giving them Wright insurance for this one year, and allowing them to return to the market next off-season with a real picture of where they are with Wright, allowed to consider what they have in their in-house-options with one more year of information available to them, and allowed to consider from a free agent field that will include, among others … Neil Walker! Why commit now?