I agree that Smith shouldn't be treated as a lock to out-shine the current incumbent. It's just that with Smith and Rosario as the in-house replacements most likely capable of stepping into a full-time job in the next year, and neither he nor Duda able to play anywhere else on the field, dealing him away would necessitate either the risky move of retaining the 32 y/o oft-injured Duda on a multi-year deal or going in a completely different direction at a time when four or five other positions are also up for grabs. That said, if Smith could say be a piece in an Adam Eaton-like trade such as the Nats pulled off this past winter (with Giolito as the anchor) where he helps net us a leadoff/CF type of guy (Eaton's busted-up knee aside) or some other position where we're weak, I certainly wouldn't hesitate to pull the trigger on it. Rosario, Conforto, and Céspedes, for all practical considerations, should be viewed as the only untouchables among position players at this point.