Rey's situation was a bit like Lagares's a couple years back: a superior defensive player at a premium position seemingly on the rise. In 1999, Ordonez was (thought to be) 24 y/o was coming off his 4th Gold Glove and, while still at the low end of the offensive scale, did manage to raise his OPS by 59 points over the previous season which was itself of 67 point jump over the one before and he was rewarded with a four year contract buying out his arbitration years. I think there was also a subtle signal by GM Phillips in that deal and a similar one given to Armando around the same time towards the just traded for/FA-to-be Mike Hampton: we're making this a good place for you to stick around by taking care of both the defense and the back end of the games behind you. Problem was that two months into the deal Ordonez had aged two years (when his real DOB was revealed), was backsliding with the bat, had mysteriously lost his defensive magic, was lost for the season with a broken arm. He'd never recover even the hint of what he once (briefly) was. Lagares got his Gold Glove in 2014 at age 25 the same year he upped his rookie year OPS by 70 points and got a five year (plus option) deal out of it. Juan hasn't lost much if anything defensively but, like Ordonez, his hitting hasn't progressed the way they hoped and now he's in a situation where his contract calls for him to be the full-time player that he's yet to prove he can be.