In defense of, well not of Wacha & Porcello themselves but the thinking behind the strategy that brought them here, they weren't supposed to be what they became which was effectively the numbers 2 & 3 starters behind JdG. They were supposed to be fighting it out to see who'd grab the 5th starter slot and who'd be the 6th starter/long reliever/backup plan. As bad as those two have been, it's been made worse by the non-attendance and/or suckitude of Thor and Gsellman and the two Long Island boys. Going back to The Shawn Estes Experiment (they opened one time for Tears For Fears) now THAT was a staff made up of five hopes and five prayers. I'm betting that the thinking was that all those 2002 starters -- Leiter, Astacio, Estes, D'Amico, Trachsel -- had at one point laid claim to being their clubs #1 starter and so IFFFFF they all simultaneously put it all together again that you'd have the making of a good staff. But of course that's the baseball equivalent of being dealt a straight flush and it wasn't going to happen; Leiter was too old, Astacio was old before his time, while Estes, Trax, and d'Amico were only briefly aces and for not particularly good SF/MIL/TB teams. This year's staff, at least as constructed and planned last winter (which now seems like it was about a decade ago) wasn't depending on getting 'career best' stuff out of either of these guys.