Not Mets related, but the umps blew this one on 4/13/08 in a Phils/Cubs game. I saw this play live on TV and couldn't believe the umps blew it. It ended up effecting the outcome of the game. ESPN wrote: Manuel earned his first ejection of the season for arguing DeRosa's homer off Jamie Moyer in the sixth that gave Chicago a 4-2 lead. DeRosa hit a high drive down the left-field line leading off the inning. Third-base umpire Adrian Johnson called it fair, though replays showed the ball was just foul. Left fielder Pat Burrell immediately trotted in to state his case and Manuel ran out to express his opinion. After the umpires refused to overturn the call following a brief meeting, Manuel continued arguing and was tossed. "I thought it was foul," Manuel said. "I saw the replay." Cubs manager Lou Piniella had a different view. "It looked fair to me," he said. Told by reporters the ball was foul, Piniella replied: "Really? You mean the umpires were wrong?" http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/recap?gameId=280413122