LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr wrote: The thing about Bruce (and any other potential QO recipients) is that he wouldn't net us an end-of-first-round pick unless he signed somewhere for $50M or more (thanks to the new CBA). If teams outside of Queens weren't interested in trading for him as a rental during a near-career-year, do you think they're paying that much over 3-plus-years to bring him on? I don't think this is correct, based on the labyrinthine rule as discussed here. It sounds like the only function of the $50M rule is to give a revenue-sharing team a higher compensation pick than it would otherwise be awarded. MLB's website wrote: The Draft-pick compensation is also based on the financial status of the free agent's former team. If a free agent who rejected a qualifying offer signs a contract that is worth at least a guaranteed $50 million in total value, and his previous club is one of the teams that receives revenue sharing, said club will be given a compensatory pick immediately following Round 1 in the next year's Draft. If such a club loses a free agent for a contract worth less than a guaranteed $50 million in total value, the club will receive a compensatory pick after Competitive Balance Round B (which follows the second round). If a qualifying-offer free agent's previous team is over the luxury-tax threshold, said team will receive a compensation pick after the fourth round has been completed. If a team neither exceeded the luxury tax in the preceding season nor receives revenue sharing, its compensatory pick will come after Competitive Balance Round B. The value of the free agent's new contract has no impact on the compensation pick in both of these cases. I'm with smg on this - assuming we do get a mid-level compensatory pick if he declines, there's no harm in QOing Bruce and, if he accepts, trading Nimmo or keeping him on as a 4th outfielder. The better outcome is that Bruce goes away, but the worst outcome is that we non-tender him and get nothing in return. Besides Walker, has any player ever accepted a QO? It's somewhere between a serious offer and a kick in the ass. But much closer to a kick in the ass. What I didn't realize about QOs until I read MLB's website is that they can only be made once in a player's career. You can't keep QOing a Bruce-level player until he forces the issue either by moving on or playing below the level where he's worth the trouble.