Vic Sage wrote: Centerfield wrote: Rodriguez was the reigning Gold Glove winner and ahead by the conventional defensive stats. There was no question slotting him in at short would have benefited the team. Jeter was selfish. Now, it may be human to not want to move positions for a douchebag, narcissistic cheater. I get that. But Jeter is just a guy. It's not fucking Saint Derek. I absolutely agree; and anything that offers criticism of saint derek i'm all for... But. He is a proud and arrogant athlete (which is redundant). And an all-star SS with his career to that point would naturally feel like the team is best served with him continuing in the position which helped the team win 4 championships. But it was not for him to decide who played SS for the Yanks. It was the manager's call. Saint Joe could've looked at the situation, seen that they were a better team with ARod at SS and asked (then demanded) Derek to move over (either to 3b or 2b). But it wasn't Derek's job to suggest it, volunteer to move, or even be happy about it. It was the Yanks' job to require it. So i have a hard time bashing Derek for THIS one. And i think writers, when they do want to criticize Derek (which is practically never) go to this one point. But its a bullshit point. If anything, it's a critique of Torre at the time, which writers are equally loathe to do. Agreed that this is Torre's call. But I also think that Torre knew that his shortstop, despite what is written about him, would have been irate that he had been removed from the position he felt entitled to play until he retired. This could have been career suicide, and Torre, despite what is written about him, knew how to protect himself even at the cost of winning. Jeter has no obligation to suggest or volunteer to move. He is, as you said, a proud and arrogant athlete. So he doesn't deserve to be bashed for it. But neither should he be deified while examples of his very human, and selfish, behavior get swept under the rug. Had Jeter offered to move over for Rodriguez, this would have been cited as just another example of him putting the team first. Instead, he didn't say a word, and A-Rod offered to move. Jeter escapes criticism, ARod is not credited for this. If Jeter really were the Saint that Verducci, Vesey, and countless other writers pretend he is, he would have volunteered to move. When A-Rod struggled in his first season at third, St. Jeter would have insisted that the move be made. And when the Yankee fans got on ARod about his throwing problems, instead of saying "ARod's a grown man, he has to work it out", he would have stood by his teammate and said "Don't boo the Gold Glover who volunteered to move for the good of the team." But he didn't. Because he's a regular guy who didn't want to move positions or support a teammate who happens to be a prick. And that was more important than winning.