Benjamin Grimm wrote: I have to wonder how guys like Walter Johnson or Christy Mathewson would fare today. 1. If they were born in 1995 and came through the same system that today's pitchers did. - OR - 2. If they emerged from a time machine and got assigned to the rosters of the Nationals and the Mets, respectively. Time Machine: They'd stand no chance. They'd get lit up every outing and eventually quit. Born in 1995: I'm not sure how you calculate the odds here, but a few nuggets to consider: Quick google search says the US Population in 1915 was about 97M ppl, 90% of whom were white. Take away the women, and you have Walter slotting in as the best pitcher in about $43.5M people. Today, the US population is about 334M people, and thankfully, all races are eligible. Since a woman has yet to crack the majors, we'll take away half the population again, leaving us 167M people. There were 24 teams in 1915, and there are 30 now, which means 6 more pitching staffs to fill out from the extra 123M eligible folks. Of course, today, Walter has to compete with folks from PR, the Dominican, Korea, Japan, Canada, Mexico, etc. Foreign born players comprise about 30% of MLB rosters. I mean, there's no way to know how Walter, specifically, would end up. But I'm sure people smarter than me could calculate the odds that he makes the majors, dominates, etc. I'd think his floor is pretty high still. Like as long as he doesn't get injured you'd think he'd at least be a high-level college player.