The rationale it seems from you and Elster is that it makes no difference how the season ends. We could have lost to the Dodgers and watched THEM get smoked by the Cardinals, or we could have lost down the stretch of the season and the Philles (or whomever) could have been smoked in the first round. Or we could be beat by the eventual Champs, and there is no difference. In other words it didn't make a difference that the Bills made it to those Super Bowls or got bounced out by their first round opponent, wheither that team was the eventual SB or AFC champion. But there IS a difference! Its the difference between Marv Levy and Jim Kelly wearing those Yellow Jackets or just being honored by the Bills organization. Its the difference between the Bobby Cox Braves winning or losing to the eventual NL Champion 9 out of 14 times or just being an also ran like the Astros, or even the Cardinals of recent vintage. Its something that really should make you sit back and say "Boy if only..." instead of "Ah we wouldn't have beaten team X anyway, you see how they got creamed by them?" Hell for a player it has to be something to latch on to for the next year. Sure no one plays to be second best, but that is something tangible to build upon. Now clearly I'm not saying the Padres should be feeling "Hey we could have been..." but then again, why wouldn't they. A few good starts by Wells, maybe Piazza's bat comes alive, you never know. Its something to build on, as a fan and as a player, that the championship went through you, and that is the rationale for rooting for the Cardinals to win the World Series.